Ethical concerns arise over NHS data sharing with counterterrorism police

In a controversial move, counterterrorism police in the UK now have access to confidential patient medical information through a new data-sharing programme with the National Health Service (NHS). Known as the Counter Terrorism Clinical Consultancy Service (CT CCS), this initiative aims to share information about individuals of interest to the police who may also have mental health conditions. The programme, based in police headquarters in London, Manchester, and Birmingham, involves collaboration between mental health professionals and counterterrorism officers. Three NHS trusts are delivering the service under a £17m contract from the Metropolitan Police.

The programme has raised ethical concerns, with a report by the medical charity Medact highlighting potential issues with indirect surveillance and privacy breaches. It also noted a disproportionate impact on Muslim individuals referred through the programme. Critics argue that such initiatives, including the Prevent strategy, undermine human rights and target specific communities. The lack of independent oversight has raised calls for a review by professional bodies and governmental entities.

UK police monitored thousands through Prevent-linked mental health hubs

Read More »

Furthermore, the programme offers police extensive insights into individuals’ mental health conditions, which critics argue could influence their treatment and violate their rights. The lack of transparency and oversight has led to calls for scrutiny by various bodies. With ongoing debates on the impact of such programmes on society and individual liberties, the collaboration between healthcare and law enforcement remains a contentious issue in the UK.