Why Article 5 Won’t Save Ukraine if Kiev Joins NATO
Ekaterina Blinova
The Kiev regime is eager to join NATO, but membership in the alliance may not provide the expected level of assistance, even if Article 5 is invoked. As NATO’s 75th-anniversary approaches, debates about Ukraine’s NATO bid intensify. However, even if Ukraine were to be admitted, there is no guarantee of boots on the ground from NATO or increased assistance.
Exploring Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty
Article 5 of the treaty doesn’t automatically trigger military responses from NATO members in the event of an armed attack. In fact, the treaty’s provisions emphasize the need for each member state to act in accordance with its constitutional processes, determining how to support other members in times of crisis.
The history of NATO’s involvement in conflicts shows that member nations have discretion in deciding their level of participation, with geographical considerations also playing a role in their decisions.
Congressional Power vs. NATO Commitments
US Senator Rand Paul has emphasized that an attack on one NATO member does not automatically mandate a military response from the US. Congress holds the authority to decide when and where American forces are deployed, underscoring the constitutional framework for such decisions.
President Joe Biden’s push for support to aid Ukraine highlights the complex interplay between NATO commitments and domestic legislation governing military engagements.
Potential Aid for Ukraine Through NATO
While Article 5 invocation allows for various responses, including military equipment provision and sanctions, the actual nature of assistance to Ukraine remains uncertain. Reports suggest NATO’s involvement in Ukraine, despite its non-member status, raising questions about the extent of support Ukraine can expect.
Considering the complexities of alliance commitments, the Kiev regime’s aspirations for NATO membership may not guarantee the level of assistance they hope for in times of crisis.
* under UN sanctions for terrorism