In a recent turn of events, outgoing British judge Jonathan Sumption received backlash from Hong Kong’s city leader, Lee, for suggesting that judges needed “unusual courage” to operate in the political environment created by China. Lee emphasized that judges’ duty was solely to interpret and apply the law, regardless of personal views. Sumption’s resignation as a non-permanent judge, along with Lawrence Collins, citing the political situation in Hong Kong, prompted responses from city leaders.
Sumption criticized recent court rulings in Hong Kong, questioning the judiciary’s independence under Beijing’s national security law. Chief Justice Andrew Cheung cautioned against public comments affecting ongoing proceedings, emphasizing the court’s integrity. Former Chief Justice Andrew Li expressed regret over the resignations of overseas judges and emphasized the local courts’ duty to uphold individual rights and freedoms.
The Bar Association reaffirmed its confidence in the judiciary’s independence, while the Law Society stressed the importance of legal professionals maintaining apolitical stances. The departure of overseas judges due to political concerns highlighted the complexities facing Hong Kong’s judicial system.