Former Chief Executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor emphasized the importance of the rule of law and judicial independence in Hong Kong amidst the departure of overseas judges from the Court of Final Appeal.
Cheng stated that the quality of the appellate mechanism is dependent on the abilities and commitment to the rule of law of the bench members, regardless of nationality. She underscored the significance of judges being able to decide cases based solely on evidence and law, highlighting the essence of judicial independence.
With the exit of overseas judges like Jonathan Sumption and Lawrence Collins, the number of foreign judges on the Court of Final Appeal has dwindled, posing potential strains on the judicial system. The presence of these judges has been seen as a vital aspect of the city’s judicial model, reinforcing confidence in Hong Kong’s rule of law.
While some suggest the city consider eliminating foreign judges, others argue that their contributions are valuable, citing the wisdom and diversity they bring to decision-making in the top court. Regardless of these changes, the judiciary’s independence and impartiality must be demonstrated through its judgments and adherence to legal principles.